PitPinTrack day riders’ news & tips, pinned daily

What 351 crashes say about junctions and solo crashes

A US federal study investigated 351 injury crashes. Most involved another vehicle, usually at an intersection, and single-vehicle crashes were far more often fatal.

3 min readUSABy PitPin Desk

The Motorcycle Crash Causation Study is the most recent large US investigation into why riders crash. It was run through the Federal Highway Administration. The crashes were investigated in Orange County, California, and the final report came out in February 2019. Life at Lean walked through it in a September video. The figures below come from the report itself.

How the study worked

The study investigated 351 injury crashes, case by case. For every crash they also gathered two control riders, matched on place, direction, day of the week and time of day, who had not crashed. Comparing the two groups shows which factors turn up more often in crashes than among those riders. The report warns: "Statistically significant differences or over- or underrepresentations may result from categorizations applied and are not necessarily indicative of cause and effect."

Other vehicles, mostly at intersections

Of the 351 crashes, 269 involved another vehicle and 82 involved the motorcycle alone. Among coded responses, the report records 76.2 per cent of crashes as multiple-vehicle and 23.8 per cent as single-vehicle. Left-turn scenarios were the most common crash configuration. Only 21.6 per cent of the multiple-vehicle crashes happened away from an intersection.

The other driver's traffic scan contributed to the crash in 70 per cent of multiple-vehicle crashes. A failure to detect a potential hazard contributed to their failure to avoid the crash in 60 per cent. In 24 of the multiple-vehicle cases, the visual background made the bike more visible, and in 54 it made the bike less noticeable.

Approaching a car waiting to turn

Life at Lean's advice for a vehicle that could turn across your path:

  1. Ease off the throttle and cover the brake as you approach.
  2. Ride slower and more predictably, to work against a misjudged gap.
  3. Look for eye contact, to see whether they are looking at you, and for a hint they are committing: body language, or a tiny rotation of the wheels.
  4. Pick a lane position that gives you the most time and space to react and avoid them if they do pull out.

The working assumption is that they will pull out in front of you until you are absolutely sure they will not, which is once you have passed them. Life at Lean applies the same thinking to driveways and to a parked car about to pull out.

Single-vehicle crashes

Of the 40 fatal crashes, 22 were single-vehicle crashes and 18 involved another vehicle. The 22 are 26.8 per cent of the 82 single-vehicle crashes, and the 18 are 6.7 per cent of the 269 multiple-vehicle crashes. In 95.1 per cent of single-vehicle crashes, the first thing the bike hit was a fixed roadside object.

Loss of control, skills deficiency and unfamiliarity with handling the bike were overrepresented in single-vehicle and fatal crashes. Single-vehicle and fatal crashes were more frequent on tighter curves. Proper execution of evasive action was underrepresented in single-vehicle and fatal crashes.

No training and self-taught riders

Riders with no motorcycle training were overrepresented in the crash group, and self-taught riders were underrepresented. The data doesn't say exactly why. Life at Lean's reading is that a certificate isn't the same thing as competence, and that a rider who consistently tries to learn and better themselves through practice, wherever that development comes from, is likely to ride safer than one who just takes a course and assumes they are doing everything correctly for the rest of their motorcycling days.

Sources